Wednesday, 16 May 2012

The connection between mother and child well-being


On May 13, the second Sunday of the month, many countries throughout the world - Cuba, United States, Australia, Bangladesh, Papua New Guinea, the Netherlands, Zambia, Honduras and Greece - paid tribute to mothers and their role in society by celebrating Mothers Day.

Despite the diversity of these countries in terms of their culture, languages spoken, history and economic wealth, one common element present within them and the world over is the importance of the role of mothers in children’s development. As documented in the Save the Children report ‘Nutritionin the First 1,000 Days, State of the World’s Mothers 2012’ the quality of children’s lives is dependent on the health, security and well-being of mothers. Providing mothers with access to education, income earning opportunities, maternal and child health care gives them and their children the best chance of survival and quality development.

The report applies a ‘Mother’s Index’ and ranks countries based on results. The index is constituted of a composite of separate objective indices for women’s and children’s well-being - which grouped into the broader areas of women’s health status; educational, economic and political status; children’s well-being - include female life expectancy, under 5 mortality rates, primary and secondary school enrolment, maternity leave benefits and ratios of male to female income earned. 

Applied to 165 countries (43 developed nations, 122 in the developing world) the index revealed stark differences between the situation for mothers in developed countries and those in the developing world with Norway ranked as the best place to be a mother and Niger the worst. The index reveals the severe inequality between countries and the degree to which mothers and their children, can and do, survive and thrive throughout the world.

The results of these objective indices are vital for revealing existing gaps and dangers, specifically related to child nutrition, and effectively focus on women as actors for change. In terms of the other aspects of children’s integral development (cognitive, socio emotional, spiritual and physical), the role of mothers is equally important and subjective as well as objective indicators of well-being are an effective way of measuring this and the situation for mothers and children beyond their mere survival.

Throughout the world mothers are the primary family caregivers and from Manhattan to Kinshasa, their emotional well-being, as well as their physical health, is highly important to the creation of a positive environment for children’s growth and development and therefore their long term well-being. Scientific studies show that children who grow up in a positive environment tend to have greater mental and emotional health throughout the course of their lives. Additionally, the maintenance of positive emotions during early childhood has an effect on self esteem and behaviour (Reynolds, 2007 & Stark 2002).

The application of subjective indicators such as those employed in the Canadian Index of Well-being - living standards, time use, community vitality, democratic engagement, and leisure and culture – would help to better ascertain how they feel about themselves, their lives, responsibilities as caregivers and their capacity to fulfil them. Such an approach would allow for insight into barriers that may hinder women’s well-being and the development of their children, for example the burden of caregiver responsibility that they carry and how without support opportunities for income generation, furthering education and free time for mothers are impeded affecting their economic, emotional and physical well-being and, their ability to breastfeed and the societal and cultural attitudes towards breast feeding.

Such detail can help to identify where greater supports are required for the benefit of mothers and in turn that of their children.

Reynolds, A., J. Temple, S. Ou, D. Robertson, J. Mersky, J. Topitzes y M. Niles (2007). Effects of a Preschool and School-Age Intervention on Adult Health and Well Being: Evidence from the Chicago Longitudinal Study. Paper presented at the biennial meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development, March 30, 2007, Boston, MA.
Stark, I. (2002). Engaging and Supporting Parents and Providers throughout A Continuum of Children´s Mental Health Services. Child Care Bulletin, spring (25), p. 7.

Friday, 11 May 2012

Week in review

Hello, glad you could join us for the Wikiprogress week in review - a handful of headlines that have caught our eyes over the last week. You can find all news articles and blog posts on the progress community in the Wikiprogress Community Portal.

Spotlight:  Canadian Index of Wellbeing Online Discussion
Have your say and be a part of the conversation shaping the future of measuring what matters. The discussion focuses on the next phase of the progress movement and seeks contribution from all interested individuals and organisations.
See more and have your say on the  Canadian Index of Wellbeing Online Discussion

Human Development Report release
Asia-Pacific Human Development Report (UNDP)
The Asia-Pacific Human Development Report “One Planet to Share: Sustaining human progress in a changing climate” is a reminder for us all that if climate change is managed in a coordinated way, it will unravel human progress now and in the days to come.
See more and contribute to the Wikiprogress article on the Human Development Index

On Rio+20
Linking the development and environmental agendas (ODI Report release)
A new ODI background note “Separated at birth, reunited in Rio? A roadmap to bring environment and development back together”  sets out to explain why reconciling the two agendas has been so difficult at a practical level, and suggests how Rio+20 could start to bridge the gaps between the two.
See more and contribute to the Wikiprogress article on sustainable development

On big data
How social media is being used by the UN to spot crises (UN Global Pulse)
In this video, Robert Kirkpatrick from the UN Global Pulse team explains how the social media revolution has opened up a significant amount of data that can be analysed to see signs of change and therefore enable us to respond to disaster quickly, rather after the fact.



On gender equality
The OECD Development Centre's 2012 Social Institutions and Gender Index (SIGI) was launched yesterday in Washington. The SIGI is an innovative measure of underlying discrimination against women for over 100 countries. While other indices measure gender inequalities in outcomes such as education and employment, the SIGI focuses instead on the underlying drivers of these inequalities and reflects changes in laws or practices.
See more on methodology, country rankings by visting the new website www.genderindex.org and follow the discussion on Twitter using #SIGI2012

We hope you will tune in the same time next week. In the meantime, if anything interesting passes your desk that you would like to see in the next Wikiprogress week in review, please tweet it to us @Wikiprogress or post it on our Facebook page.


Yours in Progress,

Philippa Lysaght

Wednesday, 9 May 2012

CRC and governments delivering on commitments: Australia’s National Children’s Commissioner


New Zealand, Britain, Sweden and Norway each have one and last week it was announced that by the end of 2012, Australia will have a National Children’s Commissioner. Sitting within the Australian Human Rights Commission, the National Commissioner’s role will be to promote the rights, well-being and development of children and young people in Australia. The Commissioner will raise awareness of issues affecting children, undertake research and education programs and monitor the Government’s legislation, policy and programs relating to children’s rights, well-being and development (Attorney General for Australia, 2012).

The responsibilities of the National Commissioner are in line with the General Measure of Implementation (GIM) of the Convention on the Rights of the Child, which states the importance of establishing co-ordinating and monitoring bodies to ensure that all children enjoy all rights of the Convention (UNHCR, 2003).

The Convention on the Rights of the child is the most ratified treaty in the world. Yet this strong show of commitment by governments is not always reflected in action. In many countries, some of the rights set out in the Convention are yet to be incorporated into national legislation meaning that although the commitment has been made at an international level, there is no legal instrument at a national level to ensure its implementation.

In Australia assessments of the quality of child well-being have shown some poor results, despite the country being a signatory to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, developed, wealthy and peaceful with low levels of poverty.

Drawing on a UNICEF IRC 2007 publication, ‘Child poverty in perspective: an overview of child well-being in rich countries’, in 2008 UNICEF Australia partnered with the Australian Research Alliance for Children and Youth (ARACY) to develop a unique report card on the wellbeing of young Australians. With the absence of internationally-agreed upon indicators of child well-being, the CRC is an ideal source of guidance and was applied in both studies to assess the situation for children. In the Australia study eight dimensions of child well-being were used for analysis:

  1. Material well-being
  2. Health and safety
  3. Educational well-being
  4. Relationships
  5. Behaviours and risks
  6. Subjective well-being
  7. Participation
  8. Environment

The findings of the report revealed that Australia’s progress was behind that of many other developed nations in some indicators. Indigenous Australian babies were found to have the lowest birth weight in the OECD and Australia ranked 20th of 27 countries for infant mortality. Teenage pregnancy rates were significantly higher than the OECD average and those for Indigenous young Australians were the highest in the OECD. School achievement for Indigenous young Australians was in the bottom 10% with only two other countries achieving lower scores, Mexico and Turkey (ARACY, 2008).

These results are indicative of how achieving and maintaining child well-being can be a complex process. The presence of peace, economic prosperity, social protection and welfare and, regulatory frameworks are all important factors that contribute to an environment conducive to promoting the well-being of children. However, other strategies are required to ensure delivery on commitments and that the specific needs of disadvantaged populations are met.  

The assurance of children’s well-being requires a holistic and multidimensional approach and coordination across ministries and between actors to ensure the social, physical, nutritional, cognitive and emotional developmental needs of children of all ages, living in all different contexts, are met. Additionally, the implementation of initiatives requires monitoring and evaluation and the measurement of progress to ensure accountability and the effective use of resources.

The move by the Australian government to prioritise children and their needs through the nomination of a National Commissioner demonstrates recognition of the importance of children’s rights and well-being and is a hugely positive step towards achieving progress in these areas and improving the situation for all children in Australia.


Wikichild Consultant
Hannah Chadwick


Australian Research Alliance for Children and Youth (ARACY), 2008, the ARACY Report Card on the Well-being of Young Australians: Technical Report, ARACY, CanberraAustralian Research

Attorney General for Australia, 2012, Gillard Government to establish National Children's Commissioner, Media Release 29.04.2012, (Accessed 07.05.2012), Available at:  http://www.attorneygeneral.gov.au/Media-releases/Pages/2012/Second%20Quarter/29-April-2012---Gillard-Government-to-establish-National-Childrens-Commissioner.aspx?zbrandid=2039&zidType=CH&zid=2771439&zsubscriberId=504179093&zbdom=http://aracy.informz.net 

Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (UNHCR), 2003, GENERAL COMMENT No. 5 (2003), General measures of implementation of the Convention on the Rights of the Child (arts. 4, 42 and 44, para. 6), (Accessed 08.05.2012), Available at: http://www.unhchr.ch/tbs/doc.nsf/898586b1dc7b4043c1256a450044f331/3bba808e47bf25a8c1256db400308b9e/$FILE/G0345514.pdf 

Save the Children Australia, 2010, National Children's commissioner: Our Position, Policy, Research and Advocacy Department, (Accessed 07.05.2012), Available at: http://www.savethechildren.org.au/resources/position-papers/national-childrens-commissioner.html 

UNICEF IRC, 2006, The General Measures of the Convention on the Rights of the Child, (Accessed 07.05.2012), Available at: http://www.unicef-irc.org/publications/415

Canadian Index of Wellbeing Online Discussion


Join the online discussion launched today: 


Have your say and be a part of the conversation shaping the future of measuring what matters.
The discussion will focus on the next phase of the progress movement and seeks contribution from all interested individuals and organisations.

Does this all sound new to you? Here is a little background on what we are talking about:

Over the last decade, organisations around the world have been developing new indicators of progress that look beyond GDP and economic growth in measuring well-being. To date, the progress discourse has focused on the development of new measures and methodologies to gauge well-being at the local, national and international levels.

Today, a new conversation is taking place: now that we have newer and smarter measures of progress, how can they be applied to policy? 

About the host
One of the leading organisations in the progress movement, the Canadian Index of Well-Being (CIW), invites you to join this conversation and have your say in the next global phase of measuring what matters and in finding out how these indicators are going to be used at the policy level.

Watch the video below and join have your say- join the online discussion here, tell us what you think or respond to key questions listed on the discussion page. 


You can aslo join the conversation on Twitter, simply use the hashtag #stats2policy

Friday, 4 May 2012

Week in review

Hello, glad you could join us for the Wikiprogress week in review - a handful of headlines that have caught our eyes over the last week. You can find all news articles and blog posts on the progress community in the Wikiprogress Community Portal.

In the Spotlight:
The 2012 ASCD Whole Child Virtual Conference runs from the 3rd - 11th of May. It explores what outstanding schools, communities, and individuals have done as they move along the whole child approach continuum from implementation to sustainability to culture.

Progress in India
In India, More Food and More Suffering (New York Times Blog 01.05.2012)
According the the Gallup well-being survey, in 2012 13% of Indians said they could not afford food, compared to 35% of people in 2006. 10% reported they did not have enough money for shelter in 2012, compared to 24% in 2006. Despite these developments, in 2012 31% of Indians, around 240 million adults, reported they are “suffering” compared to 24% in 2011.
See more and contribute to the Wikiprogress article on progress in India

On Mayday
Mayday (The Economist 01.05.2012)
To mark Mayday, a day associated with left-wing anti-government protests, the Economist created a chart showing unemployment rates before and after the financial crisis. This year, anti-government protests in Greece and Spain reflect high unemployment rates, particularly amongst the youth. Added to this pressure, on April 30th Spain was announced the 12th country in Europe to fall into recession.

See more and contribute to the Wikiprogress article on employment rates

On the Humankind Index
How we can measures Scotland’s Well-Being? New index from Oxfam (From Poverty to Power 04.05.2012)
Oxfam blogger Duncan Green comments on the recently released Humankind Index. Over 3000 people in Scotland were consulted to establish the aspects of life that matter to them the most. The index is based on the findings of this consultation, with a weighted set of elements that respondents considered affecting their ability to live well in their communities.

See more and contribute to the Wikiprogress article on progress on the Humankind Index

On data journalism
Release of the Data Journalism Handbook
The Data Journalism Handbook is the result of a 48 hour festival at MozFest in London. The book has become an international collaborative effort involving dozens of data journalists from around the world. See short video about journalism in the age of data
Find out more about the upcoming data journalism conference: Innovative Approaches to Turn Statistics into Knowledge



On gender equality
Women in Brazil Turn to Eco-Friendly Farming in Wake of Storms
In the area of Rio de Janeiro, women farmers are learning environmentally friendly techniques in response to extreme weather events and their effects on the land.
Read more about gender equality and the environment and Brazil in Wikigender.


We hope you will tune in the same time next week. In the meantime, if anything interesting passes your desk that you would like to see in the next Wikiprogress week in review, please tweet it to us @Wikiprogress or post it on our Facebook page.


Yours in Progress,
Philippa Lysaght

Wednesday, 2 May 2012

Europe, its children and tackling deprivation and poverty


There is widespread evidence supporting the argument that measuring monetary poverty and income alone result in inadequate assessments of child well-being. The multidimensional nature of child well-being requires measures which pick up on the individual components to ensure the effective tracking of progress or regression in particular areas and to allow for effective and targeted responses.

A recent study by UNICEF Innocenti on child deprivation, multidimensional poverty and monetary poverty in 29 European countries produced findings that add fuel to the fire as to why we need child well-being measures. In ranking countries according to the degree of child deprivation the study established four main groups:

      - Nordic countries and the Netherlands 10% child deprivation or less
      - EstoniaLithuania, Poland, Slovakia, Italy and Greece - approximately 25 %
      - Portugal, Bulgaria, Romania - rates higher than 25%

Results were further disaggregated into the sub groups of children with lone parents, children living in large families, children in families where the adults are not employed and/or having lower levels of education. Across all of these countries children within these groups were found to be more likely to experience deprivation and although the living standards of many countries were comparable, they had significant differences in levels of child deprivation. Additionally, even in the majority of rich countries, child deprivation levels were found to be significant.

These results are cause for concern considering the current financial and fiscal crises affecting European countries which risk worsening existing levels of child deprivation and poverty and consequently impacting on overall child well-being. Given that data used precedes the crises, the actual reality of child poverty and deprivation in the region could be much worse considering the trickledown effect of economic shocks at the state level, to households and children. See the diagram below from another UNICEF publication.

 Nevertheless, the findings of the study, through a mixture of child deprivation, multidimensional poverty and monetary poverty measures have highlighted specific areas and populations for intervention. The application of these tools to monitor and evaluate over time allow for the identification of components of child well-being and sub populations that are particularly vulnerable to external shocks, they help to build evidence of strategies which prevent impacts and to address existing issues.


Hannah Chadwick
Wikichild Consultant